In the world of contemporary romance, few tropes can rival the allure of an office-set rom-com brimming with enemies-to-lovers tension. Much like Amy Buchanan’s Let’s Call a Truce or classics like Sally Thorne’s The Hating Game and Ali Hazelwood’s The Love Hypothesis, Upasna Barath’s Comedic Timing masterfully weaves humor, longing, and a hint of rivalry into its narrative. As a 29-year-old reader, stories like this have always felt like catnip to me. Especially when the dynamic of conference-rooms filled with tension and eyes-locking across the office-kitchens is so deftly portrayed. Barath delivers a fresh take on the genre, perfectly balancing witty banter and poignant emotional beats.
Barath’s debut novel captures the essence of second chances in life, love, and even career growth. The story is not just about a long-simmering feud between two warring colleagues. But about how personal growth can lead to unexpected connections. The humor is sharp, the yearning is palpable, and the chemistry between the leads feels authentic, echoing the magic of Buchanan’s Juliana and Ben. Whose complicated dynamic eventually boils over into something unforgettable. This spicy and heartfelt tale will undoubtedly resonate with fans of contemporary romance looking for a story that feels as familiar as it is refreshing.
The Intriguing Conflict Between Two Worlds
In ‘Comedic Timing’, the sharp wit and engaging storytelling immediately reminded me of a moment in life. When everything feels both charged and utterly unpredictable. Much like Juliana, whose confidence crashes after her husband dies unexpectedly, leaving her with grieving kids and a stunted career. The protagonist navigates challenges that test her resilience. With no choice but to make it work on her own. She steps into a world of uncertainty, much like I once did when faced with balancing personal loss and professional upheaval.
“What stood out most was the tension between the characters, reminiscent of Juliana’s feud with Ben Thomas, her infuriatingly attractive colleague. Their arguments, brimming with stress and raw emotion, echo moments we all face when trying to prove ourselves in environments that feel hostile. As their lives intertwine during a career-making project, I couldn’t help but admire how the book showcases that stress, like the boardroom-clearing exchanges and even the desk-clearing kisses, can sometimes lead to unexpected growth. The story beautifully explores whether opening one’s heart again, despite a nemesis’ past threatening newfound bliss, is a risk worth taking. It’s a narrative full of charming determination, offering insights into second chances and what it truly means to feel understood.“
Exploring Workplace Dynamics in Fiction
In fiction, workplace romances often tread the fine line between humor and chaos, and Upasna Barath’s Comedic Timing captures this dynamic with flair. The story mirrors the challenges seen in Human Resources policies, turning what could be a real-life nightmare into a narrative filled with unexpected twists. Through the lens of Juliana and Ben. The book delves into their rocky courtship, marked by antagonistic, often unprofessional, and occasionally discriminatory behavior.
Their journey spans years, as they struggle against the odds to navigate their personal and professional tensions. Juliana’s quirky habit of documenting every argument she’s “won” on her company-issued laptop adds a layer of humor and self-awareness, blending workplace drama with a touch of relatable absurdity.
Barath’s storytelling highlights the comedic potential of workplace mishaps while addressing serious undertones. The tension between Juliana and Ben is both hilarious and thought-provoking, as the escalating fights feel all too real, like a potential lawsuit in the making.
The comparison between their evolving relationship and the constraints of HR guidelines brings depth to their struggles. Juliana’s use of her laptop—once a symbol of professionalism—as a space for personal expression showcases her rebellious streak. Despite their flaws, the characters are endearing, making readers reflect on their own thoughts about navigating HR complaints, relationships, and humor in professional settings.
What I liked in Let’s Call a Truce by Amy Buchanan
Chemistry That Clicks
The chemistry in Comedic Timing hits all the right notes, pulling you in from the very first moment the characters are together. It’s the kind of story where you feel like you know how it will end, with all the usual beats of romantic books. Yet, it’s the pair of people—flawed but endearing—who keep the story interesting and worth reading. Their dynamic makes you rooting for them even when their faults threaten to unravel everything. It’s rare to find a connection written with such energy that it comes through in spades.
A Sprinkle of Spice
The spice in this book doesn’t try to be wild, but it works just fine. And let’s not forget Ben—the man’s hot, and that alone is a reason to celebrate! The intimate moments, while not over the top, are OK, leaving just enough for the imagination while adding depth to the story.
Juliana’s Web of Relationships
Juliana’s relationship with her group of friends feels grounded and sweet, full of realistic interactions that readers will appreciate. There’s a plenty of banter, witty dialogues, and supportive characters who push her to confront her mistakes. The book does, at times, get lost in the weeds when focusing too much on friendships over the romance. But it’s hard to complain when the side characters are so well-developed. These friendships feel authentic, showing honest advice and even calling out Juliana when she’s being an idiot, all while providing a solid backdrop to the main narrative.
What I wasn’t crazy about in Let’s Call a Truce by Amy Buchanan
Dialogue and Language Choices
In Comedic Timing, the dialogue often feels stilted, giving the characters a glaring sense of being disconnected from reality. This is especially noticeable in the lack of contractions, which, though a nit-picky observation, stands out as a creative choice that feels unnatural in a contemporary setting. Unlike characters in real life who constantly use contractions, these characters speak as if locked in a more Victorian era, where rigid language would fit better.
Character Conflict and Avoidance
The tension between Ben and Juliana is intense, with the narrative urging readers to feel for them as they struggle with their avoidant behaviors. It becomes annoying at times, as Ben could have asked Juliana about his past much earlier. Which would have saved both characters a lot of unnecessary conflict. Instead, their pathological refusal to communicate adds to the hurtful and rude nature of their relationship, making it hard to stay invested.
Lack of Communication and Connection
On top of this, there are moments when their interaction feels as if they have never communicated with another human being before. Despite both working at the same architectural firm. The lack of social awareness makes them appear as if they are meant to be together by sheer accident. This dynamic could have been interesting but ends up seeming overly forced and awkward.
Unrealistic Relationship Evolution
While the characters struggle with emotional missteps. The overall storyline feels as if it’s pretending to avoid a more genuine relationship evolution. As the plot unfolds, it’s clear that the romantic tropes at play, including miscommunication and unresolved tension, could have used more development to make the relationship. Feel more authentic and less like an unrealistic set of events strung together.
2 thoughts on “Book Review Of ‘Let’s Call a Truce’ by Amy Buchanan”